Best of all, youll still get 21 mpg with the 6speed and 2433 mpg with the dsg, although vw recommends you grab the premium pump. Performance of the ford focus st vs golf gti engine and fuel economy. Honda has the civic type r, fords focus rs is worth having a look at, then theres the renault megane r. Debating between an automatic or manual 2011 jetta tdi. The dsg shifts faster than a human can, therefore the dsg has a faster 060 time than the manual. Dsg invariably wins 0 60 comparisons, thanks to launch control. Volkswagen california 20052015 volkswagen golf gti edition 35 20112012. In fact i go as far as saying more than half the golf r cars local to me in my price range were dsg.
Lows pricier than the already great golf gti, stickshift model is significantly slower than the automatic, too subdued for some. At the track, the manualequipped gti was the slower of our two testers. The volkswagen is a german automobile manufacturer with headquarters in wolfsburg, lower saxony, germany. When it comes to power, it might be surprising that the focus st has over 40 hp on the base gti. We are reddits central hub for vehiclerelated discussion, industry news 22 feb 2018 2 feb 2018 in respect to dsg vs manual. Jul 14, 2011 the only other expense was in swapping the sixspeed manual transmission for a dsg configuring a topoftheline gti was an easy task. When you add the gti performance package included with all nonbase 2017 trims, its still ahead by 30 hp. The tiptronic automatic shifts smoothly in automatic or manual mode. But lets say youre set on vws golf r should you stick to the manual or get the dsg instead. Nov 11, 2015 unfortunately, the manual loses to the automatic golf r against the stopwatch. I wanted a manual and wasnt at all interested in dsg. The 5speed manual gearbox is easy to shift, with a smooth, easy clutch pedal and offers improved performance 060 in 7. The original one had just 110 hp but it was light and nimble and was very easy to drive.
Volkswagen ags dsgs direct shift gearbox could be found in the mk5, mk6, and mk7 golf, gti, jetta, golf r, tdi, polo, passat, r32, beetle, tiguan, touran, cc, scirocco, a1, a3. Remember a dsg transmission is not really an full automatic its a hybrid cross between a the manual and automatic. The golf tdi offers a choice of a 6speed manual or a 6speed dualclutch automated manual, called the direct shift gearbox, or dsg. A volkswagen cc sport with the manual gearbox can accelerate from 0 to 60 mph in 6. The 5speed manual gearbox is easy to shift, with a smooth, easy clutch pedal and offers improved performance 0 60 in 7. Debating between an automatic or manual 2011 jetta tdi so, i am still waiting to hear from my insurance company, but i think i may just fork out the extra cashtake a small 6k loan to get a new vehicle rather than used since i cannot find any used tdi for a good price. Well, a gti with a dsg isnt down on acceleration from those cars, especially if you are comparing autoto dsg. I was in the same boat a few years ago when buying a mk5 golf gti.
The focus st only comes with a 6speed manual transmission. I have seen a few tests that put the gti with dsg at 5. The only other expense was in swapping the sixspeed manual transmission for a dsg configuring a topoftheline gti was an easy task. Oct 23, 2011 golf r manual v golf r dsg 0 60 posted in general chat. It is the largest automaker in the country, and the volkswagen is the companys most popular product.
The four trim levels are intuitively named for the main feature additions in. Yesterday, for the enjoyment of driving i decided to go to the vw dealer and test drive both the manual and dsg 2 door gtis. Its faster 060 and more economical than a manual whilst being much more relaxing to drive. Read on to learn more on the 2011 volkswagen gti in this first drive article brought to. The 5speed manual gearbox is easy to shift, with a smooth, easy clutch pedal. If you go for a manual threedoor, you can buy a golf r for. Immediately, i fell in love with the gtis overall refinement and quality. May 18, 2011 2011 my12 skoda octavia ii fl vrs manual hatch 2.
Gti vs 2011 kia optima sx vw gti mkvi forum vw golf r. Golf r dsg vs golf r manual 12 mile 40 roll youtube. May 07, 2011 the tiptronic automatic shifts smoothly in automatic or manual mode. Sure, the dsgdct gearboxes are tenths of a second quicker 060 and every gear change is fractions of a second quicker than a good manual shift but id. As the original hot hatch, the volkswagen golf gti is the gold standard in. One thing to note, the dsg offers greater fuel efficiency 2433 mpg vs. If you dont want to row your own gears, the gtis dsg dual. Manual v dsg grapschknutsch 14th apr 2018 im very curious, why nobody compares acceleration with a certain rpm limit. I have mkvi fixed typo gti with stage ii tuning and dsg, my friend has a new jetta with the new motor and stage i with manual tranny and he drove my gti last night and loves it and regrets getting the manual. Sure, the dsg dct gearboxes are tenths of a second quicker 0 60 and every gear change is fractions of a second quicker than a good manual shift but id trade ultimate pace for the enjoyment and. The 2011 volkswagen golf has an upscale feel thats a notch above competitors. Fast forward to today and i finally got my hands on a 2018 golf gti with a manual transmission, the way it should be. Dsg is faster hands down in 060 times as its way easier to maintain peak boost as you go into the next gear. The 220horsepower golf gti is an enthusiast favorite and the 292horsepower golf r thrills with allwheeldrive traction and 060mph acceleration in less than five seconds.
The 2011 volkswagen cc has performance that doesnt altogether match its sexy shape, and seating space is disappointing, but otherwise theres a lot to like. Notable standard equipment on the 2011 volkswagen golf begins with a 5speed manual gearbox on the 2. Eibach pro springs, koni fsd shocks and a few bling bits inside. After a threeyear hiatus, the volkswagen golf is back. Dsg is faster hands down in 0 60 times as its way easier to maintain peak boost as you go into the next gear. Volkswagen 060 times vw beetle, golf, gti, jetta, passat. Unless you are an expert who shifts perfectly every time its going to make the car quicker in day to day use too. The golf r is the understated and underrated antithesis of its redhot hatchback rivals. Ford focus st vs vw golf gti comparison cj pony parts. Weve certainly spent plenty of time testing and reporting on this dieselpowered sedans light appetite for fuel, especially on the highway where olga really shines. Dsg vs manual transmission golf gti launch control. Is the vw golf r better with a manual or automatic gearbox.
The company has undergone several changes, and currently 17% of it is held by qatar holding llc. Though not blisteringly fast our test data shows a 060 mph run of 5. Iirc the difference is around 2 tenths of a second and 12 mph. This alphabet soup of technology results in superb fuel economy. Please take into account that the volkswagen 0 to 60 times and quarter mile data listed on this car performance. The minuses are cost both purchase price and ongoing maintenance costs. However, the equally lovable and significantly less expensive golf gti. Power is supplied by a double overhead camshaft, 1. The 2011 volkswagen cc has performance that doesnt altogether match its sexy shape, and seating space is disappointing, but otherwise theres a. With the 6speed manual it is slower, but its still capable of a 6. The initial 010mph time really robs it of power, car feels like a big slouch before you hit the boost. Still the best 2018 volkswagen golf gti manual tested.
Still, a manual can get tiresome in thick traffic, and the whipcrack shifts of a dualclutch gearbox are mighty intoxicating. Unfortunately, the manual loses to the automatic golf r against the stopwatch. Thanks to mat wattson, we have the first comparison between the new golf gti with the performance pack and the equally new golf r for 2017. Dsg or manual vw golf r mk7 chat vwroc vw r owners club. The manual version of the gti gets 28 mpg combined. Vw golf r dsg v manual video 12 may 2010 they main problem with the manual, in this rather pointless 060 exercise, is that second gear doesnt take you to 60, which is a bit odd. Need mpg information on the 2020 volkswagen golf gti. Weve confronted a twodoor, manual gearboxequipped 2010 volkswagen golf tdi turbodiesel direct injection with hondas latest in smallcaliber hybrid artillery, the 2011 honda crz. Sadly, its only got one usb port, so if youre using android auto or apple carplay, no one else can charge portable devices. The tdi model offers a choice of a 6 speed manual or a 6 speed dual clutch, automated manual, called the direct shift gearbox, or dsg. Manual v dsg grapschknutsch 14th apr 2018 im very curious, why nobody compares acceleration with a certain rpm limit like staying below 3000 or 4000rpm.
335 1197 234 35 1 262 954 939 1270 1192 591 626 219 320 1010 468 1364 918 942 1378 1486 1113 1024 318 6 1094 1458 83 1120 36 1186 1063 1075 178 645 1319 1446 961 823 173 623 490